Cash for Clunkers: Everyone's a Winner

Cash for Clunkers

By Chad Brand
Seeking Alpha

It is hard to argue with the success of the “Cash for Clunkers” automobile incentive program so far. With $1 billion already blown through, Congress is working on a $2 billion extension, despite most Republicans being against the program (probably because it was a Democratic idea, not because it is not working).

So far the average consumer is trading in their clunker for a new car that gets 9 miles per gallon more than the vehicle it replaced. The sales spike during the last week of July has led both Chrysler and Ford (F) to report July sales gains, the first increase in 2 years for the domestic automobile industry. General Motors (GMGMQ.PK) reported a 19% decline in sales, but still saw an enormous benefit from the program.

It remains to be seen if car sales will be sustained at higher levels, but the glass looks half full at this point. New car inventories are near all-time lows so inventory rebuilding in coming months should boost GDP pretty significantly, perhaps leading to a positive GDP print for the third quarter.

The car companies are not the only beneficiaries, however. “Cash for Clunkers” helps consumers and the country as a whole too. Higher fuel efficiency should not be understated. Consumers will save money by spending less to fill up their gas tanks, freeing up money for other things. In addition, less pollution from the new vehicles not only is safer for Americans but the environment in general as well.

Despite skepticism from many, this program does show that smart government spending can stimulate the economy. In this case it does so in more ways than one, making the investment well worth the several billion dollars spent.