Analyst Still Rates Ford Stock as 'Strong Buy'
18 September 2000
Detroit First of Michigan Analyst Still Rates Ford Motor Co. Stock as 'Strong Buy'But Sees Lower Quarterly EPS With Firestone Situation DETROIT, Sept. 15 The following is being issued by First of Michigan, a member of the National Association of Securities Dealers, CRD number 1994975: Richard J. Hilgert, First of Michigan's automotive analyst, has issued "Strong Buy" ratings for the stocks of Ford Motor Company and three major automotive suppliers, ArvinMeritor, Inc., Lear Corp., and Tower Automotive, Inc. He has, however, reduced the current quarterly Earnings Per Share estimates for the stocks of all four companies, following Ford's announcement that it would extend the shutdown of facilities affected by the Firestone tire recall situation. "In the very near term," says Hilgert, "we think the stocks affected will continue to be under pressure as uncertainty looms with regard to another shutdown extension and the potential for further estimate reductions. In the long-run, we view this development as a one-time event, implying a window of buying opportunity for long-term holders." Ford Motor Company (F-NYSE) shares, says Hilgert, "are attractively valued and offer investors 12 month price appreciation potential to $40 per share." At the same time, "We reduced our 3Q/00 estimate for Ford by $.10 to $.41. We estimate the additional shutdown translates into approximately 7,500 Ford Rangers and 5,000 Ford Explorers, or a reduction of $270 million in revenue for the 3Q/00." "The Firestone tire development and the resulting media attention is a near-term situation that casts a cloud over investors' perception of Ford production and brand image," Hilgert advises. "Despite the media attention, Explorer demand remains strong and we see need for further manufacturing interruptions. Once the cloud dissipates, we think the stock will quickly rise to its 'pre-Firestone' levels in the high-$20 range." Commenting positively on the stock of automotive Troy, Michigan-based supplier ArvinMeritor, Inc., Hilgert said: "The combination of Meritor Automotive and Arvin Industries created an opportunity for ArvinMeritor (ARM-NYSE) to sell an expanded array of products in heavy and light vehicle markets." "As a result, we expect ArvinMeritor to achieve its long-term goal of 10% annual growth in revenue, excluding acquisitions. The favorable fundamentals created by the merger have enabled the shares to hold near their high for the year, despite a temporary external problem. This implies to us that the stock might move quickly to our $24 target, when this cloud lifts," opined Hilgert. As for the earnings per share reduction, Hilgert stated: "We have reduced ARM's 4Q/00 revenue by $3 million. Our new 4Q/00 EPS estimate is $0.56, down $0.03 from our previous EPS estimate of $0.59. ArvinMeritor has greater exhaust content on the Ranger but also supplies exhaust components for the Explorer." Southfield, Michigan-based Lear Corp. drew favorable praise from Hilgert who advised: "Lear (LEA-NYSE) is the only auto supplier capable of providing one-stop shopping for roof-to-floor complete interiors. Lear would be a logical choice for designing complete vehicle interiors for auto makers seeking to differentiate their products using electronic components." "In our view, the current stock valuation does not accurately reflect Lear's earnings potential and the trend toward greater use of vehicular electronics," says Hilgert. "We believe Lear offers investors upside potential to $40 over the next 12 moths, with longer-term potential to its former highs in the low $60 range." "We have reduced Lear's 3Q/00 revenue estimate by $5 million as a result of Ford's prolonged work stoppage. LEA has door panel, electrical distribution and electronic content on both the Ranger and Explorer," advises Hilgert. "In addition, Lear produces seat systems for the Explorer and floor and acoustic systems for the Ranger. Our new 3Q/00 EPS estimate is $0.55, down $0.04 from our previous estimate. If Ford were to recoup Ranger production, as expected, it would be a positive development for LEA's 4Q/00. However, with significant exposure in the weakening Euro, gains from the Ranger may be offset by currency effect." Tower Automotive, Inc. (TWR-NYSE) also receives a favorable review from Hilgert: "We think Tower's roll-up of the fragmented global market for structural auto components and assemblies should continue to roll out the earnings. Because of its customers' increasing demand for modular components, outsourced engineering expertise, global presence and an active acquisition strategy, we think earnings should continue to improve, giving investors upside potential to $23 over the next 12 months." Concerning Minneapolis-based Tower's near-term outlook, Hilgert says: "Tower Automotive makes frames for the Ford Ranger and structural stampings for the Ford Explorer. We estimate that the additional week of shutdown will cost TWR $3 million in revenue. Because of the week extension, we are reducing our 3Q/00 EPS estimate for TWR to $0.38, off $0.03 from our prior estimate of $0.4l."