The Auto Channel
The Largest Independent Automotive Research Resource
Official Website of the New Car Buyer

Companies Accused of 'Replacing Bad Tires With Bad Tires'

25 August 2000

Tire Action Group Accuses Companies of 'Replacing Bad Tires With Bad Tires'
    SILVER SPRING, Md., Aug. 23 A group of Ford and Firestone
owners who organized themselves on the Internet are accusing the two companies
of "replacing bad tires with bad tires."  Bob Rolls, a Silver Spring,
Maryland, disabled U.S. Navy veteran, who started the Tire Action Group (TAG)
on, said today that he and the people who have joined TAG
"plan to leave no stone unturned and won't give up the battle with Ford and
Firestone until they stop playing games with peoples' lives and conduct a full
and immediate recall of all ATX, ATX II and Wilderness tires."
    "The new tires that Ford and Firestone are using to replace recalled tires
are identical to the old tires.  It amazes me that the government is letting
them get away with this shell game," Rolls said.  "Ford and Firestone still
have not provided the public with all the available information about failures
from plants other than Decatur nor have they provided information about the
16" tires.  Available information indicates that these tires are likewise
failing."  He supported his accusations by pointing out that "about one-third
of lawsuits and about one-third of the complaints that NHTSA has received
involve failures, deaths and injuries involving tires that were excluded from
Firestone's recall."
    "The replacement tires already have a record of failure.  It is clear that
the problem with these Firestone Wilderness tires has nothing to do with where
they were made.  Tires made in Decatur may have a higher reported failure rate
but that doesn't excuse the significant number of failures of tires made
elsewhere," Rolls said.  "Before the public is asked to accept these tires as
'safe', Ford and Firestone should be required to make full disclosure of all
available information regarding the performance of these replacement tires,"
he added.
    Little Rock, Arkansas attorney, Tab Turner,'s Attorney of
Record on tires reported that about one-third of the lawsuits he has been able
to identify involve tires made at Firestone facilities other than Decatur or
are a size other than those recalled.  CBS news credited a NHTSA source for
its report that more than a third of the complaints that have come into the
agency involve Firestone Wilderness tires that were not included in the
    Furthermore, Rolls pointed to the Firestone tire failure reports he's
received on TAG's website.  "In the eight days since TAG's
website went live, we have received over fifty complaints of failures
involving 15" Wilderness tires that were not made in Decatur or 16" tires that
were not part of the recall," he reported.