Dealership Consolidation Predicted to Continue
24 January 2000
Dealership Consolidation Predicted to Continue; Polk Forecast Predicts up to 4,000 Fewer Dealerships by 2010ORLANDO, Fla., Jan. 24 -- Dealer consolidations are hot in the automotive industry and, if the trend continues, by 2005 there will be 20,770 new-car dealerships -- and by 2010, only 18,673 new-car dealerships will remain. This means that in 10 years, there would be a 17 percent drop in the number of automotive dealerships, according to a study released today by The Polk Company. Forecasted Number of New-car Dealerships Year Number 1999 22,400 2005 20,770 2010 18,673 Source: Polk Recent reports from NADA show that dealer chains represent 40 percent of all dealerships and the number of new-car dealerships has been steadily declining. In 1999, the number of new-car dealerships declined to 22,400, a loss of 6,100 dealerships since 1979. Coinciding with this overall decline in dealerships, the number of larger dealerships has increased. In 1979, 60 percent of new-car dealerships sold 150 or more vehicles, increasing to 73 percent in 1989. That number rose again to 81 percent in 1999. Historic Number of Dealerships Year New-Car Dealerships New-Car Dealerships Selling 150+ Vehicles 1979 28,500 17,000 1989 25,000 18,275 1999 22,400 18,144 Source: NADA "Manufacturers are interested in dealer consolidation, as evidenced by recent program changes such as the Ford Auto Collections," said Bill Barrett, Managing Director of dealer programs at Polk. "Because consolidating dealerships results in significant cost savings, it appears manufacturers will continue to move toward having fewer dealer franchises." Another impact of consolidation is fewer dealerships to service automotive consumers. Polk survey data show that two out of every five new vehicle buyers (38.2 percent) rated the importance of having a convenient dealership location near their home highly in their choice of a new vehicle. At the same time, consumers place a high value on having a large selection of vehicles. As dealerships consolidate, the size of dealerships and what they offer will continue to grow. Polk survey data indicates that 45 percent of consumers rated the importance of having a large selection at their new- vehicle dealership as being of "critical importance" or as "very important." Larger, consolidated dealers are capable of having greater selection available, generally have more services to offer and are able to offer more competitive pricing. "Consumers are attracted to large dealerships because they want the lowest price, which makes it difficult for the smaller dealerships to compete," said Karen Piurkowski, Polk's Director of Loyalty. "They eventually have to lower their prices, which obviously affects profits." Polk survey data indicates that 88 percent of consumers rate the importance of the total purchase price highly when purchasing their new vehicle (of "critical importance" or "very important"). This fact alone provides the larger, consolidated dealerships with a competitive advantage. NADA studies also show that larger dealers (those selling more than 300 vehicles) earned an average of $207 per vehicle, while smaller dealers (those selling fewer than 300 vehicles) experienced a loss of $66 per vehicle. Smaller dealerships' profits primarily come from used car sales and F&I (Finance and Insurance) departments. "With the number of dealerships declining, lower profits, and competition from consolidated dealers, the future is uncertain for many dealerships," said Piurkowski. "Whether this current trend means consolidation is inevitable for many dealerships remains to be seen." Polk's Manufacturer Loyalty Excelerator(TM), the basis for these findings, provides consumer behavior insight and was created to provide household loyalty information to manufacturers at various levels. Polk's Manufacturer Loyalty Excelerator(TM) determines loyalty percentages for the entire automotive industry, provides cross-industry comparisons of loyalty behavior and examines loyalty at various levels, e.g., from the industry level down to the vehicle-line level. The study measures loyalty throughout an entire model year to identify trends as they occur in the industry. Polk is a global company delivering multi-dimensional intelligence to the auto industry to enhance the relationships consumers have with brands. Through lifetime understanding of individuals, Polk helps clients maintain current customers, win new ones and build their brand loyalty. Based in Southfield, Mich., Polk is a privately held firm currently operating in Australia, Canada, China, France, Germany, Holland, Spain, the United Kingdom and the United States. Visit the Polk Web site at http://www.polk.com