Mannesmann Posts Defence Document Rejecting Vodafone's Offer
14 January 2000
Mannesmann Posts Defence Document Rejecting Vodafone's OfferMannesmann Offers More Value Today, More Value Tomorrow and Less Risk DUSSELDORF, Germany, Jan. 14 -- The following release was issued today by Mannesmann AG: * Mannesmann has today posted its defence document rejecting Vodafone's offer. * Vodafone's offer is wholly inadequate and carries significant risk. The offer fails to take proper account of Mannesmann's unique strategic position and the benefits that this will bring. Therefore, the Executive Board of Mannesmann, with the full support of the Supervisory Board, unanimously recommends shareholders to reject Vodafone's offer. Value * The Executive Board believes that Mannesmann's base value is at least euro 250 per share. This is supported by trading valuations of comparable companies and the increase in the sector since the announcement of the Orange acquisition. * This base value excludes all of the anticipated synergy benefits with Orange and the significant upside potential of data, internet and tele-commerce. The Executive Board believes that the potential value of Mannesmann including these is at least euro 350 per share. This value belongs to Mannesmann's shareholders. Vodafone's offer does not recognise this upside, nor does it include any premium for control. * Consistent with its focus on shareholder value, Mannesmann is exploring an IPO of its internet businesses in order to crystallise their substantial value. Growth * The Board believes that a focused European strategy based on an integrated approach, control and innovative leadership will achieve superior growth and returns for Mannesmann shareholders than Vodafone's proposal. A combination with Vodafone would significantly dilute Mannesmann's growth prospects: Mannesmann telecoms is forecast to deliver 39% compound earnings growth for 2000-3 compared to 24% for a Vodafone/Mannesmann combination. European Platform * The European telecoms market represents a huge growth opportunity. Mannesmann already has controlling interests in leading mobile operators in three of Europe's four largest markets and is well placed to be the European partner of choice. * The controlled operations Vodafone adds are relatively small. The biggest are Sweden and The Netherlands. Furthermore, Vodafone's offer would involve replacing Orange with Vodafone's UK business, despite the fact that Orange is substantially outperforming Vodafone in the UK by winning 30% more customers than Vodafone in the 4th quarter of 1999. Integration * Integrated products significantly increase ARPU and reduce churn and are recognised as having huge growth potential. Scale in both fixed and mobile is critical to the ability to offer these integrated products, to access best content and to launch new tele-commerce applications. Vodafone's clear lack of understanding and experience in this area will destroy value for Mannesmann shareholders. Control * The benefits of control are undeniable and are reflected in the trend towards consolidation of minority operations in the sector. Mannesmann controls over 95 per cent of its proportionate EBITDA. Vodafone would substantially dilute Mannesmann's control position and expose it to the problems that Vodafone faces in trying to convince competitors to accept Vodafone's supposedly global products. Innovation * Mannesmann has a clear track record of innovation in all its core markets. It recognised the potential impact of the internet early on and moved swiftly to position itself to benefit. Vodafone, by contrast, has only just woken up to the internet's significance and this week's announcements served to highlight just how far behind it is. Risk * Vodafone's offer carries a number of substantial risks that Mannesmann shareholders are being asked to bear without any corresponding withdrawal rights. These are real risks with significant implications for the value of the Vodafone shares being offered. Vodafone continues to provide only vague assurances, not solutions, to these important issues. Dr. Klaus Esser, Mannesmann's CEO, today said: "The choice for our shareholders is about strategy, growth and real value. Mannesmann's integrated strategy offers significantly better growth prospects than a combined entity. Integration is key for the growth in data and internet. Vodafone's offer completely fails to recognise this value and entails unacceptable risks for Mannesmann shareholders." Copies of the defence document have been posted to Mannesmann shareholders today. Additional copies can be obtained http://www.future.mannesmann.com . DISCLAIMER ON FINANCIAL PROJECTIONS BY THEIR NATURE; THE FINANCIAL PROJECTIONS CONTAINED IN THIS PRESS RELEASE INVOLVE RISK AND UNCERTAINTY BECAUSE THEY RELATE TO EVENTS AND DEPEND ON CIRCUMSTANCES THAT WILL OCCUR IN THE FUTURE; MANY OF WHICH ARE NOT WITHIN MANNESMANN'S CONTROL: ACCORDINGLY THERE CAN BE NO ASSURANCE THAT ACTUAL EVENTS AND RESULTS WILL NOT DIFFER MATERIALLY FROM THOSE EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED BY THESE PROJECTIONS.