DCR Lowers Phelps Dodge's Debt Ratings
9 December 1999
DCR Lowers Phelps Dodge's Debt RatingsCHICAGO, Dec. 8 -- Duff & Phelps Credit Rating Co. (DCR) has lowered the senior unsecured debt and commercial paper ratings of Phelps Dodge Corporation . The rating on the company's notes and debentures has been changed to 'BBB+' (Triple-B-Plus) from 'A' (Single-A), and the commercial paper rating has been revised to 'D-2' (D-Two) from 'D-1' (D-One). The ratings changes follow a review of the company's strategic, operational and financial situation in light of the completion last week of the acquisition of Cyprus Amax Minerals. (The 'BBB+' (Triple-B-Plus) rating also applies to the senior unsecured debt of Cyprus Amax, which was assumed by Phelps Dodge.) Both ratings have been removed from Rating Watch-Down, where they were placed on September 22, 1999, following the announcement that Phelps Dodge had added an almost $1 billion cash component to its combined offers for Cyprus Amax and Asarco Incorporated. The rating outlook is Stable. The downgrades primarily reflect the additional debt that has been added to the company's balance sheet relative to its post-acquisition cash-flow generating prospects. The reduced proportion of debt service that can be covered from noncopper operations is also a consideration. Phelps Dodge now has an additional $1.5 billion in debt, comprised of the nearly $700 million cash portion of its payment for the Cyprus Amax shares and about $800 million in net debt (total debt less cash) assumed in the acquisition. Phelps Dodge's debt-to-total capitalization is currently 43 percent, compared with 31 percent at September 30, 1999 (before the acquisition). Phelps Dodge has acquired about one billion pounds per year in copper production capability. That new capacity comes at higher per-unit copper cash costs, at least until the $100 million in anticipated annual cost savings and synergies are realized. As with most acquisitions, the timing and amount of such cost savings and synergies are uncertain until they happen. However, the rating incorporates DCR's view that the $100 million goal is attainable by the end of 2001, the time frame specified by the company. The existence of Phelps Dodge Industries (PDI) as a noncopper source of substantial cash flow has been an important positive consideration in Phelps Dodge's rating. Because of the growth in the debt burden due to the acquisition, the impact of PDI cash flows, expressed in terms of how many times they cover annual interest expense, has significantly diminished. Phelps Dodge continues to have sound operational and financial management with prospects for growth in both its copper and noncopper businesses. The company cites debt reduction as a top priority. How fast that debt can be reduced depends largely on copper prices. With Phelps Dodge's large copper production (about 2.4 billion pounds in 2000), sustained periods of high copper prices would enable the company to pay down a large amount of debt quickly. Conversely, a protracted period of low copper prices and/or further acquisitions would make meaningful debt reduction difficult. DCR is a leading global rating agency with 34 local market offices providing ratings and research on debt issues and insurance claims paying ability in more than 50 countries. For additional research on Phelps Dodge, visit DCR' s web site at http://www.dcrco.com (Quick Search: Phelps Dodge). DCR' s research is also available on Bloomberg at DCRand First Call' s BondCall Direct/Research Direct at http://www.firstcall.com, as well as through other third-party providers.