S&P Cuts Ratings on Old Republic Life Insurance Group
1 December 1999
S&P Cuts Ratings on Old Republic Life Insurance Group
NEW YORK--Standard & Poor's--Nov. 30, 1999-- Standard & Poor's today lowered its counterparty credit and financial strength ratings on the members of the Old Republic Life Insurance Group (the Group) to single-'A' from single-'A'-plus. The outlook has been revised to negative from stable.The Group consists of Old Republic Life Insurance Co. (ORLIC), the major operating company, and Home Owners Life Insurance Co., which reinsures ORLIC. Collectively, it is a subsidiary of Old Republic International Corp. (ORI), whose major group of operating subsidiaries is the Old Republic General Insurance Group (ORG), a group of predominantly commercial lines property/casualty insurance companies.
The downgrade is the result of the following:
Major Rating Factors:
-- Capitalization: Group capital is very strong at the double-'A'-minus level. Until early 1999, management maintained capital well into the triple-'A' range, but dividended a substantial portion of that capital to ORI upon the sale early this year of Old Republic Life Insurance Co. of New York, a former Group member with a runoff portfolio of single premium deferred annuities, to American Annuity Group. Capital is still strong for the rating, and Standard & Poor's had anticipated that management would eventually eliminate much, but not all, of the Group's excess capital. -- Membership in ORI: Although Standard & Poor's does not consider the Group to be strategically important to ORI, it does believe the Group benefits from its position as a member (in this case, longstanding) of the parent organization. Management considers the Group strategically important to ORI because of the occasional need for a life charter to support some aspect of its property/casualty operations and because of its relationship with Old Republic Minnehoma Insurance Co. (Minnehoma), a unit of ORG. Standard & Poor's incorporates an analytical benefit from the Group's implied support from ORI in its single-'A' rating. -- Business position: The Group is very small relative to the scope of ORI's consolidated operations, accounting for only 3.5% of revenues. Individual positions in the products it offers are very modest. -- Results of operations: Although GAAP results have been satisfactory, statutory losses, adjusted for prior years' tax settlements, have been incurred from 1997 through the first six months of 1999. Statutory earnings have been hurt by acquisition costs pertaining to growth in the term life insurance portfolio. The Group writes the following business: -- Credit life and disability insurance sold through auto dealers to individuals who have borrowed to purchase cars. The insurance pays off the auto loan in case of the death of the insured and maintains payments in the event of his disability. These products are offered in conjunction with extended auto warranty insurance policies sold by Minnehoma. -- Individual term life insurance sold through brokerage markets. -- Specialty accidental death and dismemberment and income protection policies sold through financial intermediaries.
Old Republic Life Insurance Group is a Security Circle Insurer, which means that it voluntarily underwent Standard & Poor's most comprehensive analysis and was assigned a rating in one of the top four categories for financial security.
OUTLOOK: NEGATIVE
The negative outlook primarily reflects the negative outlook on ORI, the business position issues outlined above, and the weak statutory earnings. Standard & Poor's expects the Group's volume of business will remain subdued, as continued growth in term life will be temporarily offset by some curtailment of writings in credit life and disability. Statutory earnings will continue to be constrained by acquisition costs and a somewhat high level of expense. The Group will continue to maintain satisfactory, if unexceptional, GAAP earnings. Capital levels will remain marginally strong for the rating, Standard & Poor's said.--CreditWire