Court Rules in Favor of DaimlerChrysler Corporation
21 October 1999
Court Rules in Favor of DaimlerChrysler CorporationJudge Tosses Out $500 Million Class Action AUBURN HILLS, Mich., Oct. 20 -- The following was released by DaimlerChrysler Corporation : A Chicago judge this afternoon dealt a setback to frivolous class actions by dismissing a lawsuit seeking more than a half a billion dollars in damages for so called "noisy" engines. Plaintiffs' lawyers filed a class action in 1996 on behalf of approximately 1.2 million owners of 1991 to 1995 Jeep Cherokees with 4.0-liter engines. DaimlerChrysler Corporation Vice President and Associate General Counsel, Lewis H. Goldfarb, praised the verdict, noting "common sense prevailed in our legal system today. Unfortunately, millions of dollars have been spent proving the obvious: it's okay for engines to make noise. "We've said from the very beginning that this case was about money for plaintiffs' lawyers, not any defect with our product," said Goldfarb. "Hopefully this decision will make class action lawyers think twice before wasting courts' time on frivolous cases." After nine weeks of trial, Judge Thomas P. Durkin of the Illinois District Court, Chancery Division, ruled this afternoon that plaintiffs failed to prove their case. While their lawyers claimed "excessive noise," one of the plaintiffs representing the class testified that this "noise" was no louder than the "ticking of a clock." In addition, DaimlerChrysler proved there was no defect with the vehicles, and the plaintiffs representing the class knew this because they drove a combined 265,000 miles on their three vehicles without complaint. DaimlerChrysler also proved that not a single engine out of the 1.2 million vehicles involved in this case ever failed because of the alleged "defect". "This case is a poster-child for class action reform," Goldfarb said. "Our legal system should protect responsible companies from abusive lawsuits, instead of giving plaintiffs' lawyers a free shot at winning the litigation lottery."