DCR Maintains Goodyear Tire at 'A-'
4 February 1999
DCR Maintains Goodyear Tire at 'A-'CHICAGO, Feb. 3 -- Duff & Phelps Credit Rating Co. (DCR) is maintaining the debt ratings of The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company in light of Goodyear's announcement that it will pay $936 million to enter into a global alliance with Sumitomo Rubber Industries, Ltd., by forming a number of joint ventures. Goodyear's senior, unsecured debt is rated 'A-' (Single-A-Minus) and its commercial paper is rated 'D-1-' (D-One-Minus). Goodyear had approximately $2.0 billion of debt at yearend 1998. Along with the significant cost synergies expected in purchasing, manufacturing and distribution, the business combinations strategically propel the partners' combined market share in Western Europe into a clear second place, ahead of Continental and behind Michelin. In Japan, Goodyear will benefit from Sumitomo`s extensive access in selling original equipment tires and rubber products to Japanese automakers, who worldwide control approximately 28 percent of total vehicle production. Goodyear will also realize net incremental EBITDA and some operating cashflow from the joint venture arrangements. However, Goodyear will likely need to finance a large portion of the $936 million cash payment with incremental debt, as the high levels of non-alliance capital spending needed to roll out its new manufacturing process technologies and to add chemicals capacity are currently resulting in only moderate free cash flow. Goodyear's financial strategy has had a target for balance-sheet debt to debt plus equity (capitalization) of roughly 30 percent with potential temporary fluctuations for acquisitions. The financing of the Sumitomo alliance will probably push Goodyear's balance-sheet debt to capitalization ratio upward to roughly 40 percent, and a rating concern is that it may take Goodyear a number of years to return to the 30 percent range. The ratings also acknowledge Goodyear's significant off-balance-sheet operating leases and sold receivables, which push this ratio up closer to 50 percent. While the debt ratings previously acknowledged that the fundamentals of the global tire industry may trigger major consolidation and that there was potential risk of acquisitions, the significant size of the incremental debt will call for DCR to closely monitor the details of the alliance as well as Goodyear's ongoing operating performance and financial planning. Particularly, DCR will focus on the plans enacted by the new joint ventures to achieve cost savings and growth synergies, Goodyear's progress in reversing a recent increase in its working capital needs and the flexibility of Goodyear's capital spending plans to respond to turbulence in regional economic environments.