General Scanning Announces Summary Judgement Decision
8 October 1998
General Scanning Announces Summary Judgement DecisionWATERTOWN, Mass., Oct. 7 -- General Scanning Inc. today announced that the United States District Court for the Northern District of California late last week issued a decision on motions for summary judgment in lieu of a trial in an action filed against the Company for alleged patent infringement by Electro Scientific Industries, Inc. ("ESI") . In December 1996, ESI filed a complaint of patent infringement against the Company alleging infringement of two patents relating to the use of 1.32 micron wavelength lasers for laser repair of memory devices. General Scanning had previously carefully studied the claims of the patents and had determined that the patents were invalid in light of prior art. The Court granted ESI's motions for summary judgment on infringement and on the issue of whether ESI committed inequitable conduct by intentionally failing to cite prior art to the U.S. Patent Office in connection with one its patents. The Court denied General Scanning's motion for summary judgment that the ESI patents are invalid due to prior art. A substantial burden is placed upon a party seeking to invalidate a patent in a motion for summary judgement. The party seeking to invalidate a patent must show that the patent is invalid by clear and convincing evidence and must prove that no genuine issues of material fact exist. While General Scanning believes that the prior art demonstrates the invalidity of ESI patents, the Court decided that certain issues of fact were raised which must be determined at trial. The case now moves into a phase of further discovery and, subsequently, to trial where General Scanning will have the opportunity to prove the invalidity of the asserted claims of the two ESI patents. Laser memory repair accounts for a relatively small part of General Scanning's total sales. To date, a limited number of systems using the disputed technology have been sold, since use of other laser wavelengths is satisfactory for many applications involving laser repair of memory devices. To the extent this news release discusses information or expectations about General Scanning's products or markets, or otherwise makes statements about the future, such statements are forward looking and are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from the statements made. Such risks include risks that ongoing litigation may be determined in a manner adverse to General Scanning, and other risks detailed in General Scanning's Annual Report on Form 10-K that has been filed with respect to the 1997 fiscal year and the Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q with respect to the fiscal second quarter 1998. General Scanning, headquartered in Watertown, MA, develops and manufactures a broad line of laser systems for a wide range of applications in the electronics, semiconductor, medical, automotive and aircraft industries. In addition, the Company produces a line of laser subsystems and components which are used in the Company's own systems as well as sold to other manufacturers of laser systems. General Scanning also designs and manufactures under ISO 9001 certification a line of thermal printers for leading medical instrument companies. For more information about General Scanning, visit the Company on the Internet at http://www.genscan.com.