Republic Files Action Against Toyota; Seeks Civil and Criminal Penalties
7 August 1997
Republic Files Action Against Toyota; Seeks Civil and Criminal PenaltiesFORT LAUDERDALE, Fla., Aug. 7 -- Republic Industries, Inc. today announced that it has been unable to work out a compromise with Toyota Motor Sales USA, Inc. regarding Republic's ownership of Toyota dealerships. Republic said it will now vigorously pursue its legal rights to achieve its objectives. Republic also announced that it has filed a petition with the Tennessee Motor Vehicle Commission seeking a declaratory judgment, injunctive relief, and civil and criminal penalties and sanctions against Toyota in relation to Republic's proposed ownership of Toyota dealerships in Tennessee. The petition asks the Commission to declare as illegal Toyota's policies which restrict a dealer's right to sell and Republic's ability to buy dealerships in Tennessee. These policies limit Republic to acquiring seven Toyota dealerships nationally over a five-year period and require Republic to waive forever its legal rights to own additional dealerships. The petition also seeks a permanent injunction forbidding enforcement of Toyota's restrictive policies until such time as Toyota approves Republic's proposed acquisition of certain dealerships in Tennessee. Steven R. Berrard, President and Co-Chief Executive Officer of Republic Industries, said, "We have acted in good faith, trying for months to work with Toyota. We have made numerous proposals and have been rejected unreasonably at every turn. In the process we have endured Toyota's malicious and misleading press releases and their deliberate attempts to damage the reputation of Republic and our dealer partners. We are no longer willing to stand by as Toyota knowingly misrepresents Republic's intentions." Mr. Berrard also stated, "Toyota has insisted that their policies take precedence over state franchise laws. These laws are designed to protect consumers and provide dealers with the right to sell their businesses to qualified buyers. We will take every legal action necessary to protect consumers and defend our rights as a qualified buyer, and the rights of entrepreneurs to sell their dealerships. We will not be intimidated by Toyota, nor will we stand idly by as Toyota attempts to intimidate small businessmen across the country. This is not the American way." Mr. Berrard continued, "This looks like an effort by Toyota to export a system that adds costs to distribution and maintains manufacturer dominance over its dealers. The American way is to encourage the development of new systems that reduce costs and provide consumers with greater choices and lower prices. We cannot understand why Toyota would discourage what is so commonly accepted in the United States by imposing its arbitrary policies on its dealers and Republic." Mr. Berrard commented further, "Republic Industries is committed to its business plan and is well on its way to implementing its strategy successfully. We have worked hard to establish partnerships with all domestic and most foreign manufacturers. Contrary to what Toyota has said, we have assembled a management team which has the most automotive experience of any dealer group in the world." Mr. Berrard concluded, "Toyota has only approved Republic's ownership of one Toyota store and one Lexus store nationwide. We are merely seeking approval of a minimal number of additional stores out of Toyota's more than 1,200 dealerships across the United States. The Toyota dealers who we would like to partner with have been recognized nationally as leaders in customer service. Republic will enhance their success with new capital and improved techniques and leadership, building Toyota's brands and adding value to its dealer network. The consumer will come to recognize this attention to outstanding customer satisfaction and good value as the cornerstone of our automotive strategy at Republic." Republic Industries, Inc. operates subsidiaries in the automotive retailing, automotive rental, automotive financial services, solid waste services, and electronic security services industries. The company owns the nation's largest chain of new vehicle dealerships and is building a chain of used car megastores which it operates under the AutoNation USA brand name. Republic also owns National Car Rental System, Inc., Alamo Rent-A-Car, Inc., Spirit Rent-A-Car, Inc., Value Rent-A-Car, Inc., and Snappy Car Rental, Inc. SOURCE Republic Industries, Inc.