Press Release: General Motors Blasts $150 Million Jury Award
06/05/96
DETROIT, PRNewswire -- General Motors Corp. today denounced a $150-million jury award to an Alabama man injured five years ago when he lost control of his Chevrolet Blazer after falling asleep on his way home from a visit to a local club. Calling the award "completely outrageous" and "a crushing blow to the concept of individual responsibility," the nation's No. 1 auto maker renewed its call for Congress and the White House to aggressively address tort reform by setting reasonable national standards for the award and the amount of personal damages. Alex Hardy, the driver of the Blazer, was seriously injured when he fell asleep at the wheel and lost control of his truck at about 3 a.m. on August 3, 1991 while driving through the tiny community of White Hall, Ala. Soon after the crash, Hardy admitted that he had fallen asleep at the wheel after drinking a few beers. After consulting with his lawyers, Hardy began to blame the accident on mechanical problems rather than his own drinking and driving. Yet, in courtroom testimony, he admitted that he was not wearing a seat beat at the time of his accident. During the trial, General Motors' experts vigorously denied the plaintiff lawyers' claim that the accident occurred when Hardy's 1987 Blazer went out-of-control because its right rear wheel and axle suddenly broke. His lawyers argued that Hardy's serious injuries were caused by a defective door latch that allowed the drivers-side door to open and Hardy to be ejected. GM said expert analysis of the wrecked Blazer showed conclusively that the axle and rear wheel broke as a result of the crash and were not the cause of it. The analysis also indicated that Hardy was injured when, unrestrained by his seat belt, he was ejected through a window. Doors that come open during rollover crashes almost always sustain severe damage. The driver's-side door of Hardy's Blazer suffered little significant damage, and, indeed, still fits and latches today. Every bit of U.S. government safety data on highway crashes indicates the GM door latch performs as well or better than those on similar vehicles manufactured by other leading auto makers. Plaintiffs at trial presented no evidence to the contrary. A General Motors spokesman pointed out that Alabama leads all 50 states in awarding excessive punitive damage awards, according to rankings by Jury Verdicts Research.