Vehicle Power Options Side by Side Comparison
![]() |
Vehicle Power Options Side by Side Comparison
Compiled By AC Intelli
Editing By Bob Gordon
The Auto Channel
But First An Editors Note: For more than 30 years The Auto Channel has provided vehicle shoppers with accurate and easy to use research tools to help them "Get Smart, Not Screwed" to eliminate a regrettable vehicle purchase. Today vehicle buyers have even more important options to consider before they pull the trigger. Here is an understandable side by side comparison of their choice of power options they need to know before buying their next vehicle. Sorry there are no Flux Capacitors, Nuclear, Water Fuel Or Fly Wheel Power...
Vehicle Power Options Side by Side Comparison
Feature
EV
ICE
Hydrogen
Mild Hybrid
Ethanol
CNG
Energy Source
Electricity
Gas/Diesel
Hydrogen gas
Gas + battery
E85 / gas
Compressed Natural Gas
Tailpipe Emissions
None
High
None
Lower
Lower CO₂
Lower than ICE
Refuel Time
30m–12h
3–5 min
3–5 min
3–5 min
3–5 min
3–5 min
Range
100–400+ mi
300–500+ mi
300–400 mi
Like ICE
Slightly lower
200–350 mi
Fueling Network
Limited/growing
Extensive
Very limited
Gas stations
Mostly Midwest
Limited / growing
Maintenance
Low
High
Low
Moderate
Like ICE
Lower than ICE
Drive Feel
Quiet, fast torque
Engine feel
EV-like
ICE w/ assist
ICE-like
ICE-like, slightly quieter
Vehicle Cost
Higher
Wide range
High
Slightly more
Similar
Similar to ICE
Fuel Cost/Mile
Low
Higher
Moderate
Moderate
Usually lower
Lower than ICE
Environmental Impact
Very low
High
Low (green H₂)
Reduced
Lower lifecycle GHG
Lower lifecycle GHG than ICE
Model Choices
Growing
Abundant
Limited
Widespread
Few (Flex-Fuel)
Limited
Incentives
Strong
Few
Some (CA, EU)
Sometimes
Regional (Midwest)
Some regional/state incentives
SEE Also: American Motorists Should Make The Choice Of Their Vehicle Power
GOOGLE AI Summary (Could Have Editorial Errors)
Choosing the Optimal Engine Type for Your Vehicle
Choosing the optimal engine type for your vehicle depends largely on your individual needs, driving habits, and priorities. Here's a breakdown of common engine types and their associated characteristics to help you make an informed decision.
1. Internal Combustion Engines (ICE)
These engines operate by igniting a mixture of fuel and air within cylinders to generate power.
- Gasoline Engines: Utilize spark plugs for ignition and are known for smooth operation and wide availability. They are generally easy to find, relatively inexpensive, and offer good acceleration. A drawback is their contribution to air pollution and climate change. {Link: According to Your AAA Network https://magazine.northeast.aaa.com/daily/life/cars-trucks/the-different-types-of-fuel-and-the-one-thats-right-for-your-car/}, cars and trucks powered by gasoline account for nearly one-fifth of all U.S. global-warming emissions.
- Diesel Engines: Ignite fuel using compressed air's heat. They offer better fuel efficiency and higher torque, making them suitable for heavy-duty and long-distance driving. They can also have a longer lifespan and some modern diesels produce lower CO2 emissions than gasoline engines. Downsides include a higher initial cost, noisier operation, and potentially higher fuel costs. They can also produce particulate matter and nitrogen oxides. {Link: FleetOwner notes https://www.fleetowner.com/fleets-explained/article/55277764/fleets-explained-different-fuel-types} that while CNG and LNG produce harmful emissions, advancements in technology make natural gas engine emissions much easier to control compared to gasoline and diesel engines.
2. Alternative Fuel Engines
- Hybrid Engines: Combine a gasoline or diesel engine with electric motors to improve fuel efficiency and reduce emissions. They achieve excellent fuel economy, especially in city driving, and have reduced greenhouse gas emissions compared to conventional cars. They offer a balance of fuel economy and range.
- Electric Vehicles (EVs): Powered solely by electricity. They produce zero tailpipe emissions, are quiet, offer swift acceleration, and are highly efficient. Challenges include limited range, higher upfront costs, and the need for charging infrastructure.
- Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicles (PHEVs): Have larger batteries than standard hybrids for longer electric range and can be charged externally, potentially further reducing fuel consumption and emissions.
- Fuel Cell Vehicles (FCVs): Use hydrogen fuel cells to generate electricity, with water as the only byproduct. They are currently less common due to limited hydrogen fueling infrastructure.
3. Engine Configurations
The arrangement of cylinders also impacts performance and size.
- Inline (Straight) Engines: Cylinders in a single line. They are compact and cost-effective, often in smaller vehicles.
- V-Type Engines: Cylinders are arranged in a "V" shape. They can accommodate more cylinders in a shorter block, balancing power and size. Popular in performance and luxury vehicles, they can be more complex to manufacture and maintain.
- Flat (Boxer) Engines: Cylinders lie flat. Known for a low center of gravity.
- Rotary (Wankel) Engines: Use a triangular rotor instead of pistons. They are compact with a good power-to-weight ratio but can be less fuel-efficient and have higher emissions.
4. CNG Engines
CNG is natural gas compressed to high pressures and stored in cylinders. CNG vehicles operate similarly to gasoline vehicles with internal combustion engines.
Pros
- Cost-Effective: CNG is generally cheaper than gasoline or diesel, which can lead to significant savings over time.
- Reduced Emissions: CNG produces fewer harmful emissions like nitrogen oxides and particulate matter, contributing to better air quality. {Link: According to FleetOwner https://www.fleetowner.com/fleets-explained/article/55277764/fleets-explained-different-fuel-types}, emissions from natural gas engines are more easily controlled compared to gasoline and diesel counterparts.
- Cleaner Combustion: CNG burns cleaner than gasoline or diesel, leading to less carbon buildup and potential engine wear and tear.
- Domestic Fuel: CNG is an abundant resource in the United States, reducing reliance on imported oil.
- Higher Octane Rating: CNG has a higher octane rating compared to gasoline, allowing for higher compression ratios and potentially more efficient fuel consumption.
- Energy Security: Using natural gas as a fuel promotes energy independence.
Cons
- Limited Refueling Infrastructure: Finding CNG stations can be difficult, particularly in less populated areas, limiting convenience.
- Reduced Driving Range: Lower energy density means CNG vehicles often have a shorter range than gasoline or diesel vehicles.
- Higher Upfront Costs: The initial purchase price for CNG vehicles is typically higher than gasoline alternatives.
- Safety Considerations: CNG is flammable and stored at high pressures, requiring specialized handling, equipment, and safety protocols for fueling and maintenance.
- Reduced Cargo Space: The large size of CNG tanks can decrease available cargo space.
- Environmental Concerns: Methane leakage during production, transport, or use is a concern due to its potency as a greenhouse gas.
5. Ethanol Engines
Ethanol is an alcohol fuel from renewable sources like corn or sugarcane. It's commonly blended with gasoline (E10), with higher blends (E15, E85) available for flex-fuel vehicles.
Pros
- Renewable Resource: Made from plants, ethanol is a renewable energy source. {Link: The U.S. Department of Energy states https://afdc.energy.gov/fuels/ethanol-fuel-basics} that cellulosic ethanol, made from non-food plants, has a better energy balance and lower lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions.
- Reduced Emissions: Ethanol burns cleaner, lowering greenhouse gas emissions and pollutants like carbon monoxide.
- Higher Octane Rating: Ethanol increases gasoline's octane, potentially improving performance.
- Reduced Reliance on Foreign Oil: Domestic ethanol production supports agriculture and reduces oil import dependence.
- Cooling Effect: Ethanol can help cool engines, potentially extending their lifespan.
Choosing an engine depends on your typical driving, fuel efficiency needs, budget, and performance and environmental priorities.