The Auto Channel
The Largest Independent Automotive Research Resource
The Largest Independent Automotive Research Resource
Official Website of the New Car Buyer

Denying Big Three a Bailout Can Be a Historic Opportunity to Get America off Oil and Save Detroit


By Edwin Black

The impulse to accede to political pressure and jobs blackmail from the Big Three for a $25 billion bailout offers America a historic turning-point opportunity. This is the country’s chance to both reform the auto industry and ignite a massive shift off of oil in one master stroke. How?

PHOTO (select to view enlarged photo)
Edwin Black
The $25 billion in lending should not go to the Big Three as a reward for consciously addicting this country to oil and subverting the alternatives. A better idea: allocate the same $25 billion in lending—but not to the big Three. Instead, offer loans at rates as low as student loans to any American citizen or fleet manager willing to buy an alternative fuel, flex-fuel, open fuel standard or alternative propulsion vehicle--new or retrofitted. This would provide an immediate incentive for Detroit and Torrance, California to spend the approximate $100 per vehicle necessary to make every car and truck a multi-fuel or open-fuel vehicle. When we say open-fuel or multi-fuel, we are not talking about the governmental cash cow currently going to the corn ethanol-big oil combine. We are talking about fuel systems that can function on all forms of combustibles from methanol—the Chinese use 50 million gallons a year while we use none to second generation biofuels such as cellulosic ethanol. There is already pending legislation advocating the open-fuel standard and the multi-fuel approach. Why wait?

At the same time, legislation should immediately eliminate the $.54 per gallon penalty tax assessed to every gallon of sugar cane ethanol that Brazil struggles to export to America’s Southeast. In the process, we should cut the $8 billion in government subsidies annually handed to the corn ethanol-big oil combine and use that money to both fund 25 percent of the bailout money and open a string of multi-fuel service stations throughout the country offering everything from compressed natural gas (CNG) to methanol to hydrogen to electric charging.

Washington can also use a portion of that $25 billion to fund surge production of alternative fuels and propulsion from trash-to-gas to hydrogen to electric. Dozens of small companies are waiting to implement their ideas or expand beyond their mom-and-pop operations into regional or national purveyors.

A few billion dollars of that loan money should also go to fund any company that will retrofit America’s existing 250 million gas consuming vehicles to alternative propulsion fuels such as compressed natural gas (CNG), electric and multi-fuel. A vehicle can be converted to CNG for $4,000 to $10,000 depending on the particular vehicle. A company in California can convert any internal combustion vehicle to electric for $10,000 to 16,000. Naturally, there would have to be a temporary suspension of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and California Air Resources Board (CARB) regulations that prohibit retrofitting cars off gasoline without being subjected to onerous bureaucratic obstruction and $50,000 to $100,000 in processing fees. The Iranians are currently converting 20 percent of their automotive fleet annually from gasoline to CNG in an effort to circumvent anticipated sanctions against its importing of gasoline. The cost in Iran is about $50 per vehicle; the vehicles go in during the morning and come out in the afternoon.

Some of those billions can also fund Big Three transition to open-fuel or multi-fuel vehicles. The cost is about $100 per vehicle. About 1.5 million vehicles are produced monthly in the United States. Carmakers can be paid by the vehicle.

If Washington funds the purchase of alternative fuel and alternative propulsion vehicles and fuels, and mandates their use, the Big Three automakers will scrap their plans for sexed up gas guzzlers and start producing and retrofitting the non-oil vehicles the entire nation needs. Fund the public, not the problem. Help the country not the corporations.

If all this sounds like a Manhattan Project, it should. The proposed Big Three bailout is $25 billion. The World War II Manhattan Project, in today’s money, only spent $22 billion.

About the author
Edwin Black is the author of "The Plan: How to Rescue Society the Day the Oil Stops--or the Day Before." For more information about Edwin and his new book visit To watch Edwin's presentation at the Western Automotive Journalists' meeting in October CLICK HERE