Why I Take No Issue with the Government Firing GM's Wagoner

by Chad Brand
Seeking Alpha
Special to The Auto Channel

Call me skeptical that since the Obama administration’s auto task force ousted General Motors (GM) CEO Rick Wagoner it means the government is going to take over and ruin the auto industry. I think Wagoner’s list of accomplishments (or lack thereof) shows that he deserved to be gone long ago. After all, GM stock went from $60 to $2 under his tenure as CEO.

As for whether the government should have the right to force him out, why shouldn’t they have the same power that any other creditor or investor would have when trying to help a company avoid bankruptcy? Private equity invests in distressed companies all the time and as a condition of such investments always has a say in the turnaround plan, including replacing a chief executive. Having such power is the only way they feel comfortable that adequate changes will be made to somewhat protect their investment.

The government is unfortunately in the driver's seat in this case because nobody else will come to GM’s aid in its current form. By doing so, however, they should have the same rights as anybody else. No more, no less. Whether they should have even tried to prevent a GM bankruptcy is another question entirely, and a very valid one at that. I have no problem with someone arguing against that, but that really has nothing to do with the Wagoner situation.

The Obama team has decided to continue the public aid that the Bush team started, probably to try and avoid further destabilizing the financial system and economy. Reasonable minds can (and are) disagree over whether that is the right thing to do or not, but Rick Wagoner had to go regardless. Don’t forget, under his leadership, even when the economy was booming GM North America was in the red.

What about Wagoner’s replacement, Fritz Henderson? Well, I don’t think the government had a hand in choosing him. He openly and proudly announced that he was a lifelong GM’er and that Rick Wagoner was his mentor. Yikes, I guess the jury is still out on whether that is change we should believe in or not.